Bug and Defect Report Email Address

NOTICE: Thank you for your continued patience with the persistent bugs affecting the JLC Online Forums. We've setup a special email address for reporting issues and defects. Reports will go directly to the assigned IT team members. Please include screenshots if you can. There were some widespread issues over the past weekend which have been resolved. However, we know that various error pop-ups are still occurring during post composition and at other times. Thanks again. Here's the email address:
See more
See less

Rigid foam over cellulose

  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Rigid foam over cellulose

    I tried searching past threads but came up short. I have old cellulose in attic, and want to increase insulation. Ceiling is sheet rock over plaster. I can get a good price for soem rigid foam, but if I apply that perpendicular to the ceiling joists, will I trap moisture underneath? I could leave a small gap between boards, and not get that much air infiltration ( convection) Thanks.

  • #2
    Re: Rigid foam over cellulose

    You'd potentially be inviting a moisture issue to create a layer of cellulose in between the rigid foam and an attic floor that is presumably an incomplete air barrier. Potential air leakage into this cavity from from the living space below could be problematic.

    Assuming you have good access to the attic, a better bet would be to thoroughly seal the attic floor with spray foam and caulk, close any chases that are open to the attic, and simply adding more cellulose on top.


    • #3
      Re: Rigid foam over cellulose

      I think you're basically asking the wrong question.
      You could install enough thickness of foam boards, properly detailed, where moisture accumulation would not be an issue.
      But, the best, most cost-effective improvements to your attic are to first find and fix air leaks and second add more insulation.
      Foam boards don't usually make economic sense in an open attic. Per R value, foam boards are expensive, and labor-intensive to install, compared to blown insulation.
      For what it costs at the home center for 2" blueboard (a little over $1/sf for R-12 or so), you could blow in about R-30 of cellulose.
      Incidentally, in my area, paying an insulation contractor to blow insulation in costs about the same as "doing it yourself" so do get some prices.
      For info on air sealing, check the ENERGY STAR Attic Air Sealing page:

      Favorite tool this week: Leatherman Wave

      Three types of gas tank hot water heaters for your renovation
      Three types of furnace for your renovation
      Deconstruction: the thrifty, green start to your remodeling project


      • #4
        Re: Rigid foam over cellulose

        Rigid on top of cellulose would be risky,for sure. Under the cells and sealed to the ceiling or joists would be good,I think.
        I've used it quite a bit to cap exterior wall lines where there isn't room to get much fiber, sometimes placing it from the soffit.

        Foundation or crawlspace is the best place for rigid foam though>.:)